Wild mushrooms

DIna00

Veteran
Joined
10 Jan 2015
Local time
3:00 AM
Messages
244
Location
Northeastern USA
Does anyone forage for wild mushrooms? How do you know which are the correct ones to pick?

My dad and I used to do this when I was young but he never explained to me which mushrooms were good, I would just scout for any mushrooms then he'd come along and decide whether to pick them or not. We would them dry them in the oven and store them in a jar to use later.

Does anyone have experiences with picking wild mushrooms?
 
I know some, but it is now the wrong time of year in the northern hemisphere and you need experience and need to be out with someone with experience if you are not to either kill yourself and whoever says your food, or leave them seriously ill. There are plenty of instances of near fatalities, so the only advice I will give is to go out with someone who had that experience and learn from them in the field.
 
You do need to be careful because some poisonous fungi looks very similar to edible ones. The best thing to do is go out with an expert or to get an expert to check what you have just picked.

It is possible to learn how to identify different fungi and build up your knowledge so that you can be sure of getting it right. You will need a good field guide to fungi in your area and to know which ones to look for and where to look for them.

Luckily where I live the best mushrooms to eat are QUITE easy to identify when you know what to look for. I still check them carefully against my guide book.

Last year I picked and ate wild mushrooms for the first time and they tasted better than anything sold in the supermarkets.
 
This is a subject that has interested me for a long time. There are always several kinds of mushrooms to be found where I live. No matter what time of the year, they are growing and I look at them and wonder which are safe to eat or whether I am seeing something deadly. I absolutely love mushrooms but I always buy them because I have no clue how to tell the good from the bad.
If you look at them and study them online you just end up feeling like you know less than you did before you started, so I'm sure the suggestion to work with a living, breathing expert is the only sensible solution.
I wish I knew one.:)
 
I only like the grey kind of mushroom that I can get from the store rather cheaply, so I've never had to bother with going out and finding mushrooms that grow in the wild. I'm too afraid I'd pick the wrong ones since I've got nobody who could be considered a field expert or knowledgeable in that area to help. Frankly, I'm pretty sure edible mushrooms don't grow in this part of my new home.
 
i forage late summer early autumn ,i look for a type called bay boletus and field mushrooms,i would never pick what i do not know as for every edible mush there is a deadly variety similar
 
Keep it simple.
Books used to be my method of identification. Taking with me an old Collins gem. When I got home I would get out a large A4 book with better pictures and descriptions BUT less mushrooms in it.
I now use apps (as well) they are not perfect but they have advantages. They allow you to describe different parts of the mushroom and therefore eliminating mushrooms as you go through the app.
Despite what people think it's quite hard to make mistake mushroom picking. Firstly if you cannot identity then don't eat it! Also there is huge amount of exaggeration over the dangers of mushroom picking. Poison nowadays is defined as anything that has a detrimental affect on your health, no matter how minor or short term. This is a rough way of looking at it.
1/ Edible (yummy)
2/ inedible: looks like crap, taste like crap...may even be crap!
3/ Suspicious: No agreement on. May be like Asparagus ie some peoples pee stinks after eating it, others peoples does not.
4/ Poisonous: A mild stomach ache
5/ Very poisonous: Bad stomach ache no known deaths but possible if you were in poor medical condition.
6/ Welcome to death: 8 hours of extreme stomach ache 8 hours of relief (the poison is still attacking your liver\kidneys) followed by 8 hours of extreme pain.....dead. If you are treated within 24 hours and assuming reasonable medical condition you will still need a kidney/liver transplant. There is only 3 of these. Note when I use stomach ache it's just being used for comparison. Fly Agaric for instance, the mushrooms they give Reindeer is an Hallucinogenic. It's the red "toadstool"
Another thing worth noting: There is no scientific difference between a toadstool and mushroom. Nor is there agreement on what is and isn't a toadstool. There are far more poisonous mushrooms than toadstools, although not proportionally.
It should also be noted that the difference between two mushrooms which grow in the same place which you are warned about making a mistake over are invariably significantly different.
The fairy ring champignon and a mushroom called clitocybe....something like that! The mistake is made in certain weather conditions when the caps maybe the same color. The actual differences, ignoring cap color is huge. You have to be stupid or ignorant to mix the two up. Assuming your not the former putting some effort in will protect you from mistakes, Obvious mistakes.
The exception and where most poisonings occur is between the field mushroom and the yellow stainer. Now these do look like but they don't grow in the same place, Stainer prefers wood margins (inside). When cut it is supposed to go yellow along the cut, personally I don't see this But the foot always has very bright yellow splodges. It is also supposed to turn into a yellow mush when cooked.
Edit..it doesn't taste like the field mushroom either.
If you want to take up mushroom (fungi) picking but don't want to spend your time worrying, then follow these rules.
Specialise. The most obvious being field and fairy ring. The latter is in abundance spring to autumn. Remove the stem as it is very fibrous. I have yet to try dehydrating it but this is the most obvious one for dehydrating. Stuff in small jar and top up with oil adding whatever takes your fancy garlic being the obvious one. I do this with tomatoes every year and wait one year before using.
Don't mix them and if it is a new mushroom keep two back one for the A&E doctor and one for the coroner!!
Also note locations and check the same places every year.
You could of course specialise in mushrooms which you cannot make a mistake with the puffballs and ink cap for instance.
Personally I think people should avoid all wild mushrooms.....and leave them for me!
 
Last edited:
I know some, but it is now the wrong time of year in the northern hemisphere and you need experience and need to be out with someone with experience if you are not to either kill yourself and whoever says your food, or leave them seriously ill. There are plenty of instances of near fatalities, so the only advice I will give is to go out with someone who had that experience and learn from them in the field.
Every year there is a few fatalities. There is lot more in cars or cycles.
St George's Mushroom and there is one mushroom which remains undamaged and edible even when frozen solid. Named? I can't be bothered. The 3 apps I have don't allow an actual search based on season. Although they do tell you when it is growing once you have identified it.
http://www.mushroomdiary.co.uk/tag/winter-mushroom/
http://www.wildmushroomsonline.co.uk/Winter-Mushroom/index.php
 
You could of course specialise in mushrooms which you cannot make a mistake with the puffballs and ink cap for instance.
A surprising number of people can mistake earth balls for puffballs and even ignore the fact that puffballs are meant to be white all the way through and earth balls are brown/black inside! Earth balls being poisonous, puffballs being quite nice to eat. So you can never take it for granted with the human race, someone will always prove you wrong.
 
I can imagine that wild mushrooms would be delicious to say the least but it does seem like too much of a risk to me. Obviously there are the deadly ones to watch out for but in all honesty, I'm not certain what the hallucinogenic ones look like either! They are quite common in the UK and it's quite usual to see young men scouring the playing field near my house on autumn mornings. I can't think what else they're looking for!
 
I can imagine that wild mushrooms would be delicious to say the least but it does seem like too much of a risk to me. Obviously there are the deadly ones to watch out for but in all honesty, I'm not certain what the hallucinogenic ones look like either! They are quite common in the UK and it's quite usual to see young men scouring the playing field near my house on autumn mornings. I can't think what else they're looking for!
Don't be a wimp! Drive a car, ride a bike, pick wild mushrooms!!! The latter is safer!
 
Last edited:
No one does - that's the point.
Well if you can't be bothered to do the research you won't. No one knows? Really? Why have all these professors been given research money and not one of them knows what a hallucinogenic mushroom looks like!
Fly agaric for a starter.
 
A surprising number of people can mistake earth balls for puffballs and even ignore the fact that puffballs are meant to be white all the way through and earth balls are brown/black inside! Earth balls being poisonous, puffballs being quite nice to eat. So you can never take it for granted with the human race, someone will always prove you wrong.
Exactly! They bare minimal resemblance to puffballs including the exterior. As I have already stated do your research.
http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mushroom_poisoning
 
No one does - that's the point.

PS I am told that in France if you are not sure you go to a pharmacist. It appears that French pharmacist know what they look like. You do have a point though some that are Hallucinogenic and also give some people a stomach ache....I have been doing my research. NO! I mean reading up!
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom