Olives - love them or hate them?

P

Pilgrim

Regular Member
Joined
23 Apr 2024
Local time
2:20 AM
Messages
53
Location
USA
(Mod Comment: Posts moved to form a new thread. KK)

msmofet said:
I worked at a pizza place many decades ago, and we didn't make salad like that. LOL Things must have changed. I don't usually order salad from a pizza place. The last few times I did order a salad, there were the sliced black olives on it. YUCK! For some reason, I think the sliced black olives have a metallic flavor, taste like the can.
Click to expand...
To me, all olives taste the same. Whole or sliced, so I'm not a big fan of them.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Pilgrim said:
To me, all olives taste the same.
Click to expand...
Maybe that's because you've only tried the processed ones out of cans. Castelvetrano olives taste of butter, Kalamatas are slightly smoky and fruity, Lebanese cracked olives are piquant and salty, Spanish gordales remind me of freshly cut grass, and my favourite of all, Moroccan dried black olives. Just super-perfumed.
 
karadekoolaid said:
Maybe that's because you've only tried the processed ones out of cans. Castelvetrano olives taste of butter, Kalamatas are slightly smoky and fruity, Lebanese cracked olives are piquant and salty, Spanish gordales remind me of freshly cut grass, and my favourite of all, Moroccan dried black olives. Just super-perfumed.
Click to expand...
Yeah, you might be right! I'll set up an olive tasting today! Thanks a lot!
 
Olives are a staple food in the Meditteranean and Middle East, where the shrub originated, and have been around for thousands of years. These days, olives are also grown in the USA, Australia, New Zealand and several countries is South America
 
karadekoolaid said:
Olives are a staple food in the Meditteranean and Middle East, where the shrub originated, and have been around for thousands of years. These days, olives are also grown in the USA, Australia, New Zealand and several countries is South America
Click to expand...
Who started with those black canned ones? They just taste so much better out of a jar!

My DH likes blue cheese stuffed, I like garlic stuffed. We both like pimento stuffed.
 
JAS_OH1 said:
Who started with those black canned ones? They just taste so much better out of a jar!

My DH likes blue cheese stuffed, I like garlic stuffed. We both like pimento stuffed.
Click to expand...

I prefer them unstuffed. I want to taste the olives themselves and then I can pair them with other ingredients. Its best to buy with the stone in, as this retains their flavour much better.

I'd agree that jarred ones are better but I think we probably get very different brands/types in the UK. Its difficult to compare.
 
I just stocked up on some Lebanese stuffed olives (stuffed with red pepper, but in a heavily paprika-flavoured brine) and some Lebanese cracked olives. Additionalli, I've got kalamata and Moroccan cured olives, as well as a jar of "black olives in brine"
The last ones, as well as the tinned olives, are the ones I usually try and avoid. only in my cupboard for emergencies because they're basically flavourless - a bit like tinned mushrooms.
 
karadekoolaid said:
I just stocked up on some Lebanese stuffed olives (stuffed with red pepper, but in a heavily paprika-flavoured brine) and some Lebanese cracked olives. Additionalli, I've got kalamata and Moroccan cured olives, as well as a jar of "black olives in brine"
The last ones, as well as the tinned olives, are the ones I usually try and avoid. only in my cupboard for emergencies because they're basically flavourless - a bit like tinned mushrooms.
Click to expand...
Kalamatas are my favorites I think.
Morning Glory said:
I prefer them unstuffed. I want to taste the olives themselves and then I can pair them with other ingredients. Its best to buy with the stone in, as this retains their flavour much better.

I'd agree that jarred ones are better but I think we probably get very different brands/types in the UK. Its difficult to compare.
Click to expand...
How do you get the pits (stones) out? I bought them like that and got complaints from everyone so I buy pitted now.
 
JAS_OH1 said:
Who started with those black canned ones?
Click to expand...
Apparently it was a French chef, Nicolas Appert, in the early 19th century.
JAS_OH1 said:
They just taste so much better out of a jar!
Click to expand...
And even better out the barrel. Lebanese, Turkish, Greek and Spanish markets will sell them to you by weight, straight from the barrel, where they were simply brined.
 
karadekoolaid said:
Apparently it was a French chef, Nicolas Appert, in the early 19th century.

And even better out the barrel. Lebanese, Turkish, Greek and Spanish markets will sell them to you by weight, straight from the barrel, where they were simply brined.
Click to expand...
We have olive bars at some supermarkets and small family-owned grocers. Yum.
 
Morning Glory said:
I prefer them unstuffed.
Click to expand...
Me too. There are literally hundreds of varieties, so hundreds of different flavour profiles. Probably the worst are those ready sliced things, which taste of nothing, or rubber bands.
I'll eat them all, however. Stuffed olives come in a remarkable number of varieties these days. I've had them stuffed with pimiento, garlic, anchovy, salmon, blue cheese, chestnut (they are really good!), jalapeño and rocoto chiles. All good!
 
karadekoolaid said:
Jungle Jim's (the international market and favourite grazing place for TastyReuben) has a really good selection.
And in Morning Glory 's home town, there is (or was) a Turkish grocery with 8-10 different varieties.
Click to expand...
Yeah, since Cincinnati is about 3 hours each way from my house, I don't go there very often, LOL! I am planning on going through that area on our way south but we won't have time to stop and shop...
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom