• I’ve added a casual chat room to CookingBites as a place for off-topic banter, light conversation, and short-lived chit-chat that doesn’t belong in forum threads. The chat room is informal and lightly-to-not moderated, with messages being temporary, so it’s ideal for friendly back-and-forth that would otherwise derail discussions. Site rules still apply, but there’s no reporting system or expectation of post-by-post moderation - if something becomes uncomfortable, the right response is to step away. If a topic has substance or lasting value, it still belongs in the forums; everything else can head to chat.

What are you baking today (2026)?

I have some pizza dough. Have several options. Pizza, ham and cheese calzone, sausage bread. Maybe one of each. I’ll figure it out later. Been awake and up since 4:00am. Going take a nap and then decide.
I have leftover pizza toppings that should be used - grated/sliced cheeses, salami slices, sauce - need to make some pizza dough 😁
 
I'm like you
To me liquid is liquid and I use that to calculate hydration.
There is another school of thought as well though, and they only count water (and then they make a 50% hydration (egg)dough as they are not counting the eggs :scratchhead:
I've seen that. But also wonder about the effect of the additional liquid, so always factor in the egg as total liquid and go from there which works for me. I make a lot of brioche type rolls and bread - i.e. with an added egg. Gives a really great rise and texture. Funnily enough tho, I don't factor in little sploshes (usually abt a tablespoon) of EVOO or butter.

Need a chemist!

I go with water content for water. If an egg is 75% water then a 60g egg counts as 45g water.
Am seeing that. Obviously when a recipe works and used regularly - however we get to the version - it doesn't matter how you calculate it to begin with, as long as it works. What becomes interesting is when you adapt a recipe you use, for a different ingredient like you're doing.

Your earlier post:
The crumb isn't as open as I'd like so using a smaller hydration isn't going to help that. Next go around I'll figure for 73%, trial and error!
Were you using a recipe/formula you'd used before or was it new? Interested in the effect of the whey properties on the dough as well as hydration effects that you mention
 
...
Your earlier post:

Were you using a recipe/formula you'd used before or was it new? Interested in the effect of the whey properties on the dough as well as hydration effects that you mention

Wouldn't go with a new recipe and a new ingredient simultaneously. I wouldn't know best how to diagnose an issue! This recipe is pretty much my standard bread dough.

I was reflecting on the crumb and the rise and I think I know what happened. Adding whole chia seeds is what tanked it. The bran, just like in whole wheat, would've cut the gluten strands thus minimizing the rise. I'm going to make another batch here in a bit but this time it'll just be:
  • Flour
  • Whey
  • Salt
  • Yeast
🤞
 
Asked, as somewhere you were mentioning wanted to get a more open crumb/texture, which would be helped by using a higher gluten i.e. bread flour. Would also give more lift ✈️
 
Asked, as somewhere you were mentioning wanted to get a more open crumb/texture, which would be helped by using a higher gluten i.e. bread flour. Would also give more lift ✈️
Yes, but I'm not paying what they want for bread flour and with this go around I only wanted to change one thing at a time, the liquid. When I want more gluten:
1000056334.jpg


I can tell the whey has protein in it since the bread was chewy like I had added gluten but I didn't. The crumb collapsed a bit when I poured the dough into the baking pan and there was no oven spring. Still better than the first shot. 👍
 
I can tell the whey has protein in it since the bread was chewy like I had added gluten but I didn't.
Handy to know that.
When I do add extra vital gluten by percentage calculation to dough for whatever reason, it ends up as quite a small amount when viewed by teaspoon, doesn't take much

Bulk quantities of bread flour.

Do you not shape your bread before placing in the loaf pan or bowl/basket?
 
Thank you. Don't know what you mean by doesn't matte

Handy to know that.
When I do add extra vital gluten by percentage calculation to dough for whatever reason, it ends up as quite a small amount when viewed by teaspoon, doesn't take much

Bulk quantities of bread flour.

Do you not shape your bread before placing in the loaf pan or bowl/basket?

Yes, from my knowledge vital gluten is added in very small amounts.
 
Handy to know that.
When I do add extra vital gluten by percentage calculation to dough for whatever reason, it ends up as quite a small amount when viewed by teaspoon, doesn't take much

Bulk quantities of bread flour.

Do you not shape your bread before placing in the loaf pan or bowl/basket?
Depends on the hydration. This one was too wet for that but I've got banneton baskets and silicone things and all that.
 
Back
Top Bottom